1705134096
Finally, the Deputy Prime Minister should add at least one new argument to the debate—an argument that is different from yet supportive of the arguments presented by the Prime Minister. The purpose of the new argument is to demonstrate that the Deputy Prime Minister takes more than a supportive role in that debate—that he or she is able to construct independent arguments as well as refute and support previous arguments.
1705134097
1705134099
6.5 Summary
1705134100
1705134101
This chapter has focused on how the First Government Team creates arguments in support of their interpretation of the motion. Because of its importance in the overall debate, much of the focus has been on the speech of the Prime Minister. The chapter introduced the components of the First Government case, including defining and interpreting the motion, clarifying and specifying the position that the First Government will advocate and defend, and constructing a series of arguments to support the case.
1705134102
1705134103
The chapter then focused briefly on the role of the Deputy Prime Minister. That role includes refuting arguments offered by the Leader of Opposition, supporting arguments made by the Prime Minister, and constructing independent arguments to support the Prime Minister’s interpretation of the motion.
1705134104
1705134105
本章中，作者着重介绍了正方上院应该如何进行论证才能有效地支撑他们对于辩题的解读。鉴于首相在整场辩论中的重要地位，作者重点关注了首相的演讲，详细介绍了正方上院立论框架的组成，包括定义和解读辩题、表明正方上院的立场以及用一系列论证来充实本方立论框架、支持本方观点。
1705134106
1705134107
此外，本章节简要介绍了副首相的角色和职能，其中包括反驳反对党党魁提出的论点、拥护首相提出的论点，并提出新的论点支持其对辩题的解读等。
1705134108
1705134110
6.6 Terms and Concepts from Chapter 6
1705134111
1705134112
Check your memory and comprehension by describing or defining these key terms and concepts:
1705134113
1705134114
· First Government Team’s right to define and interpret the motion
1705134115
1705134116
· Reasonable person standard for definitions and interpretations
1705134117
1705134118
· Prime Minister’s responsibility to describe the Government Team’s position
1705134119
1705134120
· Model of the motion
1705134121
1705134122
· Three specifications common to a model
1705134123
1705134124
· Deputy Prime Minister’s obligations (refute, rebuild, construct)
1705134125
1705134126
· Describe, associate, evaluate pattern of argument construction
1705134127
1705134129
6.7 Discussion Questions for Chapter 6
1705134130
1705134131
· How does the Prime Minister’s obligation to provide a statement of advocacy for a value motion differ from the obligation to provide a model for a policy motion?
1705134132
1705134133
· Discuss the Prime Minister’s right to define and interpret the motion and the concomitant responsibility to do so in a reasonable fashion.
1705134134
1705134136
6.8 Exercises for Chapter 6
1705134137
1705134138
· Exercise 1:
1705134139
1705134140
For Prime Minster Speech: Present a motion to a group of debaters who are divided into teams of two persons each. Give them 15 minutes to discuss the motion and to create a Prime Minister’s speech for the motion. Give each team three minutes to present an outline of their speech. After each team has presented their outline, discuss the cases focusing on the arguments suggested as well as whether the outline suggests the speech meets the fundamental obligations of the Prime Minister speech.
1705134141
1705134142
1705134143
1705134144
· Exercise 2:
1705134145
[
上一页 ]
[ :1.705134096e+09 ]
[
下一页 ]