1705137433
4 The odd-even system adopted in Beijing during the 2008 Olympic Games mandated that automobiles with licenses ending in odd numbers could be driven only on odd numbered dates and that those with licenses ending in even numbers could be driven only on even numbered dates. An exception was made for taxis.
1705137434
1705137435
5 The category system adopted here closely follows Olbrechts-Tyteca, Lucie and Chaim Perelman, only making slight changes to the names of some of their categories to make them work better for common usage. Although changed substantially, the discussions in this chapter follow the author’s treatment of evidence in an earlier work called Discovering the World Through Debate: A practical guide to educational debate for debaters, coaches and judges. (Trapp, Robert, William Driscoll, Jurate Motiejunaite, and Joseph P. Zompetti. New York: IDEA Press, 2005.)
1705137436
1705137437
6 More will be said about how to construct an adequate argument by example in Chapter 21 on fallacies.
1705137438
1705137439
7 Actually, even indifference can in some cases be an expression of value—that something does not even merit discussion or consideration.
1705137440
1705137441
8 The original term that Stephen Toulmin used was “warrant.” This text uses the simpler and more direct term, “link.”
1705137442
1705137443
9 Links are so central that they sometimes define the nature of the argument itself. Links are described by the phrase “argument by.” Eg. “argument by generalization,” “argument by analogy,” etc.
1705137444
1705137445
10 The reference to “slam dunk” comes from the sport of basketball. When a player is left virtually alone on the court with the ball, the player may forcefully “dunk” the ball into the basket, hence, “slam dunk.”
1705137446
1705137447
11 As stated earlier, Toulmin’s terms are changed slightly in this text for purposes of clarity. He used the terms “claim, data, warrant, and reservation,” whereas, this text uses the terms “claim, evidence, link, and exception.”
1705137448
1705137449
12 The first person to write about utilitarianism was Jeremy Bentha. (Bentham, Jeremy. An Introduction to the Principles of Morals and Legislation. London: Clarendon Press, 1789.) A more recent description of utilitarianism can be found in Sandel, Michael and Justice, J. What’s the Right Thing to Do. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 2009: 31-57.
1705137450
1705137451
13 Perhaps an East Asian audience would be more likely to positively evaluate the Viet Cong (Vietnamese who fought against the Americans in the “Great American War”) whereas a European or North American audience might positively evaluate American Revolutionary War Soldiers.
1705137452
1705137453
1705137454
1705137455
1705137457
思辨精英：英语辩论-构筑全球视角 Part FiveTeaching and Coaching Debate
1705137458
1705137459
Debate coaches are primarily teachers. They teach their own students during practice sessions and sometimes in classes; when the teacher-coach attends a tournament with his or her students, he or she will be a judge at the tournament. An effective teacher-coach, first and foremost, must be familiar with the principles of debate. One can become an excellent teacher even if he or she is not an outstanding debater and even if he or she did not participate in debate at all. So, the first things that a teacher-coach needs to do are to carefully review the materials in the first four parts of this text and review other books about argumentation and debating. Only then will the teacher-coach be able to impart these principles to his or her students.
1705137460
1705137461
Beyond the need to become familiar with principles of debate, a teacher-coach will almost certainly be called on to judge debates at tournaments that his or her students attend. Chapter 22 is about the subject of judging and evaluating debates. Some, but not all, teacher-coaches will be called on to help administer and conduct debate tournaments. Sometimes the tournament will be on the teacher-coach’s campus so he or she will be the primary tournament administrator. Other times, he or she will be asked by some other tournament host to help administer a tournament. Chapter 23 focuses on the skills needed to be an effective tournament administrator.
1705137462
1705137463
1705137464
1705137465
1705137467
思辨精英：英语辩论-构筑全球视角 Chapter 22Judging and Evaluating Debates
1705137468
1705137469
Una Kimokeo-Goes
1705137470
1705137471
Chapter Outline
1705137472
1705137473
22.1 Mechanics of Judging Worlds-Style Debate
1705137474
1705137475
22.2 Guidelines for Speaker Points
1705137476
1705137477
22.3 Judge as Educator
1705137478
1705137479
22.4 Summary
1705137480
1705137481
22.5 Terms and Concepts from Chapter 22
1705137482
[
上一页 ]
[ :1.705137433e+09 ]
[
下一页 ]