1707347200
77 Besymenski, p. 368.
1707347201
1707347202
78 Seaton, p. 91.
1707347203
1707347204
79 Khrushchev Remembers, pp. 158—160, 163—164.
1707347205
1707347206
80 Besymenski, pp. 282—298 (Timoshenko’s report of 7 December 1940). David M. Glantz,Stumbling Colossus:The Red Army on the Eve of World War(Lawrence,Kan.,1998),第 89 页,称 1940 年 5 月 8 日的这份报告是伏罗希洛夫和铁木辛哥共同完成的。但这个日期是铁木辛哥接任国防人民委员的日期,不是报告的日期。当时铁木辛哥从红军总部接收了背景材料,但是没有证据显示伏罗希洛夫帮助起草了这份最终在 1940 年 12 月 7 日上交的报告。
1707347207
1707347208
81 Bonwetsch, p. 186; Besymenski, p. 98; Louis Rotundo, ‘Stalin and the Outbreak of War in 1941’, Journal of Contemporary History, 24 (1989), p. 280; Glantz, Military Strategy, p. 92; Glantz, Stumbling Colossus, p. 107; and see Zhukov, vol. 1, pp. 228, 244—245.
1707347209
1707347210
82 Mark von Hagen, ‘Soviet Soldiers and Officers on the Eve of the German Invasion. Toward a Description of Social Psychology and Political Attitudes’, in Robert W. Thurston and Bernd Bonwetsch (eds.), The People’s War. Responses to World War II in the Soviet Union, Urbana/Chicago, 2000, pp. 191—199.
1707347211
1707347212
83 John Erickson, The Road to Stalingrad. Stalin’s War with Germany, vol. 1, London, paperback edn., 1998, pp. 62—64. 关于苏军在军备、交通与防御方面的不足,另见 Zhukov,vol. 1,第 233—243 页。
1707347213
1707347214
84 Jacques Sapir, ‘The Economics of War in the Soviet Union during World War II’, in Kershaw and Lewin, p. 216. 红军在巴巴罗萨行动前夕的弱点和对战争行动的不适应,见 David M. Glantz,“The Red Army in 1941”,in David M. Glantz(ed.),The Initial Period of War on the Eastern Front,22 June—August 1941(London,1993),第 1—39 页;David M. Glantz,Barbarossa:Hitler’s Invasion of Russia 1941(Stroud,2001),第 22—28 页。
1707347215
1707347216
85 Gorodetsky, pp. 116—117; Sapir, pp. 210—211; Glantz, Military Strategy, pp. 65—66.
1707347217
1707347218
86 John Erickson, ‘Threat Identification and Strategic Appraisal by the Soviet Union 1930—1941’, in E. R. May (ed.), Knowing One’s Enemies. Intelligence Assessment between the Two World Wars, Princeton, 1983, pp. 416—418; Whaley, pp. 175, 181, 199, 223, 228, 242; Roberts, Unholy Alliance, pp. 187, 213; Glantz, Military Strategy, pp. 61—62. 红军总参谋部一直假定德军需要 10 到 15 天才能完成动员和部署,因此排除了突然袭击的可能性(Glantz,Stumbling Colossus,第 96 页)。
1707347219
1707347220
87 Gorodetsky, p. 126. The continuity of strategic thinking, also under Zhukov, is also stressed by Glantz, Military Strategy, pp. 87—88. 朱可夫后来(Zhukov,vol. 1,第 245 页)说:“军事战略主要是建立在只有发起进攻才能打败侵略者的正确观念基础上。”
1707347221
1707347222
88 Besymenski, pp. 355—363. See also Glantz, Military Strategy, pp. 70—75; and Glantz, Stumbling Colossus, pp. 90—92.
1707347223
1707347224
89 Quoted in Glantz, Stumbling Colossus, p. 93 and Besymenski, p. 364. Zhukov,vol. 1,第 250 页,朱可夫回忆斯大林说过:“没有这些重要资源,纳粹德国就不可能打一场持久的大仗。”
1707347225
1707347226
90 Besymenski, pp. 364—365; 1941 god, vol. 1, docs. 95, 134; Evan Mawdsley, ‘Crossing the Rubicon. Soviet Plans for Offensive War in 1940—1941’, International History Review, 25 (2003), pp. 821—823; Gorodetsky, pp. 122—124; Jacob Kipp, ‘Soviet War Planning’, in Glanz, Initial Period of War, pp. 46—47; Glantz, Military Strategy, pp. 78—81.
1707347227
1707347228
91 Gorodetsky, p. 127. For the proceedings of the conference, see Erickson, Road to Stalingrad, pp. 40—46.
1707347229
1707347230
92 Gorodetsky, pp. 128—129; Mawdsley, ‘Crossing the Rubicon’, pp. 825—827; Erickson, Road to Stalingrad, pp. 50—55; Glantz, Military Strategy, pp. 81—86; Zhukov, vol. 1, pp. 221—225.
1707347231
1707347232
93 Mawdsley, ‘Crossing the Rubicon’, pp. 827—832; 1941 god, vol. 1, doc. 315; extracts in Besymenski, pp. 365—367; Zhukov, vol. 1, p. 250.
1707347233
1707347234
94 Mawdsley,‘Crossing the Rubicon’, pp. 827—829; Besymenski, p. 368; Glantz, Stumbling Colossus, pp. 100—102, 108. 确实已经部署到位的部队缺乏武器装备和弹药,没有运输手段,受限于糟糕的通讯条件,见 Catherine Merridale,Ivan’s War:The Red Army 1939—1945(London,2005),第 87—90 页。
1707347235
1707347236
95 Besymenski, pp. 368—370.
1707347237
1707347238
96 Richard Overy, Russia’s War, London, 1997, pp. 64—65. 另见 Rotundo,第 282 页;Glantz,Military Strategy,第 75 页,第 79 页;Glantz,Stumbling Colossus,第 88 页,“因为缺少资源,虽然我们对给予了沿着新边界构筑防御体系最高的优先级别,但到 1941 年 6 月为止,两条防线都没有准备就绪,也没有驻军”。See also Zhukov, vol. 1, pp. 251—253.
1707347239
1707347240
97 Mikoyan, p. 377.
1707347241
1707347242
98 Winston S. Churchill, The Second World War, vol. 4: The Hinge of Fate, London, 1951, p. 443.
1707347243
1707347244
99 Gorodetsky, pp. 113—114; Roberts, Unholy Alliance, p. 205.
1707347245
1707347246
100 Quoted in Gorodetsky, p. 174.
1707347247
1707347248
101 Gorodetsky,第 173 页,第 176 页(及第 8 章);Zhukov,vol. 1,第 268 页,不过此处的用词与前者引用的俄语版朱可夫回忆录略有不同;Whaley,第 62—63 页。Mikoyan,第 377 页,斯大林表达了类似的观点:“如果我们参战,这对英国大大有利,但对我们来说,再多旁观一会儿是有利的。”
1707347249
[
上一页 ]
[ :1.7073472e+09 ]
[
下一页 ]